Last updated on September 25th, 2023 at 10:20 pm
5 Top Hole-in-the-Wall Restaurants in Buffalo
These five top hole-in-the-wall restaurants in Buffalo offer a diverse range of culinary experiences that capture the essence of the city’s vibrant food scene. From the authentic Mexican flavors of Taqueria Los Mayas to the delightful Greek cuisine at Amy’s Place, each establishment brings its own unique charm and signature dishes to the table. Now you know why they are some of the best restaurants in Buffalo for you to discover.
So, while we’ve highlighted five remarkable establishments, we encourage you to venture off the beaten path and explore Buffalo’s culinary landscape further. Keep an eye out for those unassuming storefronts and tucked-away spots where delectable surprises await.
A lot of great options are in these posts!
3 Top Comfort-Food Restaurants in Buffalo
1. Amy’s Place
Address: 3234 Main St, Buffalo, NY 14214
Phone Number: (716) 832-6666
Amy’s Place is one of the top hole-in-the-wall restaurants in Buffalo. It has been serving delicious meals to locals and visitors alike for over 30 years. This family-owned and operated establishment has become a staple in the community and is known for its warm and welcoming atmosphere.
The restaurant is a casual diner-style eatery, with a cozy and retro ambiance. It has a loyal following of regular customers who appreciate its unpretentious charm and friendly service. Amy’s Place is located in the University Heights neighborhood, close to the University at Buffalo, making it a popular spot for students and faculty.
One of the standout features of Amy’s Place is its diverse menu, which offers a variety of dishes inspired by American and Mediterranean cuisines. However, the restaurant is particularly famous for its delicious vegetarian and vegan options. Their signature dish is the “Veggie Wet Shoes,” a hearty sandwich filled with grilled vegetables, feta cheese, and homemade tzatziki sauce, served on fresh pita bread. It has gained a cult following among both vegetarians and meat-eaters for its delicious flavors and generous portions.
Main Menu Items:
1. “Veggie Wet Shoes”: Grilled vegetables, feta cheese, and homemade tzatziki sauce served on fresh pita bread.
2. “Chicken Souvlaki Wrap”: Grilled marinated chicken, lettuce, tomato, onion, and tzatziki sauce wrapped in a warm pita.
3. “Gyro Plate”: Seasoned gyro meat served with pita bread, tzatziki sauce, Greek salad, and your choice of rice or fries.
4. “Buffalo Burger”: A juicy beef patty topped with melted cheese, crispy bacon, and tangy buffalo sauce, served with fries.
– “Amy’s Place is my go-to spot for delicious vegetarian food in Buffalo. The Veggie Wet Shoes sandwich is absolutely amazing and packed with flavor. The staff is always friendly, and the atmosphere is cozy. Highly recommended!”
– “I stumbled upon Amy’s Place while visiting Buffalo, and I’m so glad I did. The Chicken Souvlaki Wrap was one of the best wraps I’ve ever had. The ingredients were fresh, and the portion size was perfect. I can’t wait to go back!”
– “Amy’s Place is a hidden gem in Buffalo. The Gyro Plate is fantastic, and their fries are crispy and delicious. The restaurant has a great vibe, and the prices are very reasonable. Definitely a must-visit if you’re in the area.”
Amy’s Place is a family-owned and operated hole-in-the-wall restaurant located in Buffalo’s University Heights neighborhood. With over 30 years of operation, this cozy diner-style eatery has become a local favorite. Known for its welcoming atmosphere, diverse menu, and especially its vegetarian and vegan options, Amy’s Place offers delicious and generous portions of Mediterranean-inspired dishes. They are one of the top hole-in-the-wall restaurants in Buffalo. Whether you’re a vegetarian, a meat lover, or simply looking for a tasty meal, Amy’s Place is a must-visit destination in Buffalo. They rank in the top hole-in-the-wall restaurants in Buffalo for good reasons.
2. Taqueria Los Mayas
Address: 3525 Genesee St, Buffalo, NY 14225
Phone Number: (716) 634-0627
Taqueria Los Mayas is one of the popular hole-in-the-wall restaurants in Buffalo. It has been delighting customers with its authentic Mexican cuisine for over a decade. This family-owned and operated establishment prides itself on providing a welcoming and friendly atmosphere for diners.
The restaurant is a casual and cozy eatery, with vibrant decor and a lively ambiance. It is situated in the Cheektowaga area of Buffalo, making it easily accessible for locals and visitors alike. Taqueria Los Mayas is known for its commitment to serving traditional Mexican dishes using high-quality ingredients and time-honored recipes.
Taqueria Los Mayas is renowned for its delicious tacos. Their signature dish is the “Al Pastor Tacos,” which feature marinated pork cooked on a vertical spit, similar to shawarma. The tender and flavorful pork is served on soft corn tortillas and topped with fresh cilantro, diced onions, and a squeeze of lime. These tacos perfectly capture the authentic flavors of Mexican street food and have gained a loyal following among locals.
Main Menu Items:
1. “Al Pastor Tacos”: Marinated pork cooked on a vertical spit, served on soft corn tortillas with cilantro, onions, and lime.
2. “Carnitas Burrito”: Slow-cooked seasoned pork wrapped in a large flour tortilla with rice, beans, cheese, lettuce, and salsa.
3. “Enchiladas Verdes”: Rolled corn tortillas filled with your choice of meat (chicken, beef, or cheese), topped with tangy green sauce, melted cheese, and sour cream.
4. “Chiles Rellenos”: Poblano peppers stuffed with cheese or seasoned ground beef, dipped in egg batter, fried to perfection, and served with rice, beans, and salsa.
“Taqueria Los Mayas is the real deal when it comes to authentic Mexican food. The Al Pastor Tacos are amazing, and the flavors transport me back to Mexico. The service is friendly, and the prices are very reasonable. It’s a hidden gem in Buffalo!”
“I’ve been coming to Taqueria Los Mayas for years, and it never disappoints. The Carnitas Burrito is my go-to order, and it’s always packed with tender and flavorful pork. The portion sizes are generous, and the staff is always welcoming. Highly recommend!”
“If you’re craving Mexican food in Buffalo, you have to try Taqueria Los Mayas. Their Enchiladas Verdes are fantastic, and the green sauce has just the right amount of tanginess. The atmosphere is lively and festive, making it a fun place to enjoy a meal with friends.”
Taqueria Los Mayas is a family-owned and operated hole-in-the-wall restaurant located in the Cheektowaga area of Buffalo. With over a decade of operation, this casual and vibrant eatery has become a go-to destination for authentic Mexican cuisine. Known for their mouthwatering Al Pastor Tacos and a menu featuring a variety of traditional dishes, Taqueria Los Mayas captures the flavors and spirit of Mexican street food. They are one of the popular hole-in-the-wall restaurants in Buffalo. With friendly service, generous portions, and reasonable prices, this hidden gem offers an enjoyable dining experience for all Mexican food enthusiasts in Buffalo. They stand out among the top hole-in-the-wall restaurants in Buffalo.
3. The Black Sheep Restaurant & Bar
Address: 367 Connecticut St, Buffalo, NY 14213
Phone Number: (716) 884-1100
The Black Sheep Restaurant & Bar is another of the top hole-in-the-wall restaurants in Buffalo. This hidden culinary gem has been delighting locals and visitors with its unique and innovative dishes for several years. The restaurant is known for its cozy and intimate atmosphere, making it a popular spot for food enthusiasts looking for a memorable dining experience.
The Black Sheep Restaurant & Bar specializes in modern American cuisine with a twist. Their menu showcases a fusion of flavors, drawing inspiration from various culinary traditions. As a family-owned and operated establishment, The Black Sheep takes great pride in providing exceptional service and a warm, welcoming environment to its guests.
The Black Sheep is famous for its “Lamb Burger,” which has become a staple and a highlight of their menu. The Lamb Burger is made with a juicy and flavorful lamb patty, topped with tangy feta cheese, caramelized onions, and a house-made aioli sauce. Served on a freshly baked bun, this signature dish perfectly exemplifies the restaurant’s commitment to creating unique and delicious flavor combinations.
Main Menu Items:
1. “Lamb Burger”: A juicy lamb patty topped with feta cheese, caramelized onions, and a house-made aioli sauce, served on a freshly baked bun.
2. “Bacon-Wrapped Meatloaf”: Classic meatloaf wrapped in smoky bacon, served with mashed potatoes, roasted vegetables, and a savory pan gravy.
3. “Pan-Seared Scallops”: Tender scallops seared to perfection and served with a flavorful parsnip puree, sautéed spinach, and a citrus beurre blanc sauce.
4. “Eggplant Napoleon”: Layers of breaded and fried eggplant, fresh mozzarella, basil, and marinara sauce, served with a side of mixed greens.
“The Black Sheep is a hidden gem in Buffalo. The Lamb Burger is outstanding, and the combination of flavors is simply divine. The atmosphere is cozy and inviting, and the staff is attentive and knowledgeable. It’s a must-visit for any food lover.”
“The Bacon-Wrapped Meatloaf at The Black Sheep is comfort food at its finest. The meatloaf is flavorful and moist, and the bacon adds a smoky touch. The portions are generous, and the presentation is top-notch. I can’t recommend it enough!”
“The Black Sheep offers an exceptional dining experience. The Pan-Seared Scallops were cooked to perfection and paired perfectly with the parsnip puree. The attention to detail in each dish is evident, and the service is excellent. It’s a culinary gem in Buffalo!”
The Black Sheep Restaurant & Bar is a family-owned and operated hole-in-the-wall restaurant located in Buffalo’s Connecticut Street neighborhood. With its unique and innovative approach to modern American cuisine, this hidden gem has garnered a loyal following among food enthusiasts. From their renowned Lamb Burger to their creative and well-executed menu items, The Black Sheep delivers memorable flavor combinations in a cozy and intimate setting. They are another of the top hole-in-the-wall restaurants in Buffalo.With exceptional service and attention to detail, it’s no wonder why this restaurant has become a must-visit destination for locals and visitors seeking a distinctive dining experience in Buffalo. They deserve to be ranked among the top hole-in-the-wall restaurants in Buffalo.
4. The Pink
Address: 223 Allen St, Buffalo, NY 14201
Phone Number: (716) 881-9868
The Pink is a popular hole-in-the-wall restaurant nestled on Allen Street in Buffalo, New York. This iconic eatery has been serving its loyal customers for several decades and has become a local institution. The Pink exudes a nostalgic and retro vibe, attracting both longtime residents and curious visitors looking to experience a slice of Buffalo’s culinary history.
The restaurant is one of the favorite hole-in-the-wall restaurants in Buffalo and a classic American diner, known for its comforting and hearty fare. Operating since the mid-20th century, The Pink has become a staple in the city’s food scene. It is family-owned and operated, with generations of the same family running the establishment. This familial touch adds to the warm and welcoming atmosphere that keeps patrons coming back year after year.
The Pink is renowned for its “Buffalo’s Original Steak Sandwich.” This iconic sandwich features thin slices of tender steak, grilled to perfection, served on a freshly baked kimmelweck roll. The sandwich is traditionally garnished with horseradish and accompanied by a side of au jus for dipping. The Pink’s version of this classic dish is a true testament to Buffalo’s culinary heritage and continues to be a favorite among locals and visitors alike.
Main Menu Items:
1. “Buffalo’s Original Steak Sandwich”: Thinly sliced steak on a kimmelweck roll, garnished with horseradish and served with au jus for dipping.
2. “Buffalo Chicken Wing Soup”: A hearty soup with a rich broth, chunks of chicken, carrots, celery, and the flavors of classic Buffalo chicken wings.
3. “Philly Cheesesteak”: Sliced steak, grilled onions, and melted cheese served on a hoagie roll, capturing the essence of the iconic Philadelphia sandwich.
4. “Chicken Finger Sub”: Crispy chicken fingers topped with lettuce, tomato, and your choice of sauce, served on a sub roll.
“The Pink is a Buffalo institution. The Original Steak Sandwich is a must-try, and it lives up to the hype. The steak is juicy, the roll is perfectly soft, and the horseradish gives it a delightful kick. The Pink captures the essence of the city’s culinary heritage.”
“If you’re a fan of Buffalo wings, you have to try The Pink’s Buffalo Chicken Wing Soup. It’s packed with flavor and captures the taste of traditional wings. The staff is friendly, and the vintage decor adds to the charm. A must-visit spot in Buffalo!”
“The Pink is a hidden gem in Buffalo. The Philly Cheesesteak is outstanding, and it rivals the ones you’d find in Philadelphia. The portions are generous, and the service is prompt. The Pink is a classic diner experience that shouldn’t be missed.”
The Pink, a family-owned and operated hole-in-the-wall restaurant located on Allen Street in Buffalo, is a cherished institution in the city. With its classic American diner ambiance and comforting menu, The Pink has been serving its loyal customers for generations. From the iconic Original Steak Sandwich to the Buffalo Chicken Wing Soup, their signature dishes capture the essence of Buffalo’s culinary heritage. They are one of the favorite hole-in-the-wall restaurants in Buffalo. With its warm and nostalgic atmosphere, The Pink offers a unique dining experience that continues to attract locals and visitors seeking a taste of authentic Buffalo cuisine. They have earned the rank of being one of the top hole-in-the-wall restaurants in Buffalo.
5. Globe Market
Address: 762 Elmwood Ave, Buffalo, NY 14222
Phone Number: (716) 886-5242
Globe Market is one of the popular hole-in-the-wall restaurants in Buffalo. This hole-in-the-wall restaurant combines the charm of a neighborhood cafe with the offerings of a gourmet market. It has been operating for over a decade, earning a reputation for its high-quality ingredients, artisanal products, and delicious food. Globe Market is situated in the Elmwood Village, a vibrant and eclectic area of the city.
The restaurant is known for its commitment to locally sourced and organic ingredients, offering a farm-to-table experience. It is a family-owned and operated establishment, and the owners’ passion for good food and community shines through in every aspect of Globe Market.
Globe Market is famous for its “Roast Beef on Weck.” This classic Buffalo sandwich features thinly sliced, tender roast beef piled high on a kimmelweck roll. The roll is topped with caraway seeds and coarse salt, giving it a distinctive flavor. The sandwich is often served with a side of horseradish and au jus for dipping, providing a satisfying and flavorful experience.
Main Menu Items:
1. “Roast Beef on Weck”: Thinly sliced roast beef piled on a kimmelweck roll with caraway seeds and coarse salt, served with horseradish and au jus.
2. “Turkey and Brie Sandwich”: Sliced turkey breast, creamy brie cheese, cranberry mayo, and mixed greens on fresh bread.
3. “Caprese Panini”: Fresh mozzarella, ripe tomatoes, basil, and balsamic glaze pressed between slices of artisan bread.
4. “Greek Salad”: A refreshing salad with mixed greens, Kalamata olives, feta cheese, cucumbers, red onions, and Greek dressing.
“Globe Market is a hidden gem in Buffalo. Their Roast Beef on Weck is one of the best in the city. The meat is tender, the roll is fresh, and the horseradish packs a punch. The atmosphere is cozy, and the staff is friendly. A must-visit for any food lover.”
“I love the variety and quality of food at Globe Market. The Turkey and Brie Sandwich is a personal favorite, and the combination of flavors is delightful. The ingredients are fresh, and the portion sizes are generous. It’s a great place to grab a quick and delicious lunch.”
“Globe Market is a local gem. The Caprese Panini is fantastic, and the bread is perfectly toasted. The staff is attentive, and the market section offers a great selection of specialty products. It’s a wonderful spot to enjoy a tasty meal and support local producers.”
Globe Market, located in Buffalo’s Elmwood Village, is a family-owned and operated hole-in-the-wall restaurant and gourmet market. With a focus on locally sourced and organic ingredients, this hidden gem offers a farm-to-table experience. From their renowned Roast Beef on Weck to their delicious sandwiches and salads, Globe Market serves high-quality, flavorful food. The cozy atmosphere and friendly staff add to the overall charm of the place. They are one of the popular hole-in-the-wall restaurants in Buffalo. Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite or browsing the market section for specialty products, Globe Market is a destination for food lovers looking for a taste of Buffalo’s culinary scene. They can definitely be counted among the top hole-in-the-wall restaurants in Buffalo.
So, while we’ve highlighted five remarkable establishments, we encourage you to venture off the beaten path and explore Buffalo’s culinary landscape further. Keep an eye out for those unassuming storefronts and tucked-away spots where delectable surprises await. Whether you stumble upon a hidden gem or receive a local recommendation, Buffalo’s hole-in-the-wall joints are sure to leave you with a satisfied palate and a memorable dining experience.
However, it’s important to note that this list is by no means exhaustive. Buffalo is home to numerous other exceptional hole-in-the-wall restaurants waiting to be discovered by adventurous food enthusiasts. Whatever you’re craving, there are hidden gems throughout the city that can satisfy your hunger. This is why they are some of the best restaurants in Buffalo for you to discover.
You May Want to Join The World Recipes With Our Big Escape
Share your own recipes in our Facebook Group. Find recipes from all over the world. Learn more about International Cuisine and how you can surprise you family with new and exciting foods from all over the world.
For More Photos Visit Our Instagram at World Recipes Daily – Our Big Escape