5 Evansville Top Hole-in-the-Wall Restaurants
In Evansville, IN, we’ve had the privilege of exploring five Evansville top hole-in-the-wall restaurants, each offering its own unique charm and flavors. From the authentic Nepali and Indian cuisine at Yak & Yeti to the comforting classics at Cross Eyed Cricket, these hidden gems have consistently proven that exceptional dining experiences can often be found in unassuming places.
Whether you’re craving the soul-satisfying barbecue at Hickory Pit Stop, the rich Italian flavors of House of Como, or the hearty homestyle dishes at Peep Hole Bar, Evansville has something special to offer for every palate and preference.
However, it’s important to note that these five Evansville top hole-in-the-wall restaurants are just a glimpse into the thriving food scene of Evansville. The city is brimming with countless more hole-in-the-wall treasures waiting to be discovered by adventurous food enthusiasts. The keyword “one of the Evansville top hole-in-the-wall restaurants” aptly describes the essence of these eateries – they may be tucked away, but they’re truly among the best. This is why these are some of the Evansville top hole-in-the-wall restaurants that are waiting for you to discover them. This list is in no particular order.
1) Hickory Pit Stop
Address: 1521 N Main St.
Hickory Pit Stop, located in Evansville, IN, is renowned as one of the city’s top hole-in-the-wall restaurants. This unassuming gem boasts a rich history dating back to its establishment in 1986 and is proudly family-owned and operated. Tucked away from the bustling streets, it exudes a cozy, down-to-earth ambiance that immediately makes you feel like you’ve stumbled upon a well-kept secret.
Hickory Pit Stop’s claim to fame is undoubtedly their mouthwatering smoked barbecue. Their signature dish, the “Pitmaster’s Platter,” is a carnivore’s dream come true. It features a generous assortment of slow-smoked meats, including tender pulled pork, succulent brisket, and flavorful ribs, all expertly seasoned and cooked to perfection. Served with a side of their famous homemade barbecue sauce and a choice of delectable sides, this platter is a must-try for anyone visiting the restaurant.
Main Menu Items:
1. Smoked Pulled Pork Sandwich: Hickory Pit Stop’s smoked pulled pork is renowned for its juicy tenderness and smoky flavor. Served on a fresh, fluffy bun and topped with coleslaw, it’s a classic favorite that keeps patrons coming back for more.
2. Brisket Platter: For those seeking a hearty meal, the brisket platter is a top choice. Slices of perfectly smoked brisket are served with a side of their signature barbecue sauce, complemented by your choice of sides. The melt-in-your-mouth texture and robust flavor of the brisket make it a standout dish.
3. BBQ Ribs: Hickory Pit Stop takes ribs to a whole new level. Their slow-cooked barbecue ribs are fall-off-the-bone tender and slathered in a finger-licking sauce that strikes the perfect balance between sweet and smoky. A true barbecue lover’s delight.
Customer Reviews:
“I stumbled upon Hickory Pit Stop while exploring Evansville, and what a find it was! The pulled pork sandwich was out of this world, and the cozy atmosphere made me feel right at home.”
“The brisket platter at Hickory Pit Stop is a game-changer. It’s the best brisket I’ve had outside of Texas. The family-run vibe here is so inviting, and the staff is incredibly friendly.”
“If you’re in Evansville and you love barbecue, you’ve got to try Hickory Pit Stop. Those ribs were incredible! It’s a true hole-in-the-wall gem and one of my new favorite spots.”
Hickory Pit Stop, a family-owned establishment with deep-rooted history, stands as one of the Evansville top hole-in-the-wall restaurants. Their signature Pitmaster’s Platter, alongside menu items like the Smoked Pulled Pork Sandwich, Brisket Platter, and BBQ Ribs, showcases the artistry of their barbecue craft. They are one of the Evansville top hole-in-the-wall restaurants.
As evidenced by glowing customer reviews, it’s clear that Hickory Pit Stop’s warm atmosphere and exceptional smoked meats have earned it a well-deserved place among Evansville’s culinary treasures. They rank high among the Evansville top hole-in-the-wall restaurants for good reasons.
2) House of Como
Address: 2002 Speaker Rd.
Nestled in the heart of Evansville, IN, the House of Como is a well-kept secret, often whispered about as one of the city’s top hole-in-the-wall restaurants. This charming eatery is a true family-owned and operated establishment, where the essence of tradition and passion for food collide. Its unassuming façade belies the culinary treasure trove that awaits inside.
House of Como has earned its reputation for its delectable Italian cuisine, and their signature dish, the “Como’s Classic Lasagna,” is a testament to their culinary expertise. Layers of perfectly cooked pasta, rich meat sauce, creamy béchamel, and a blend of cheeses are harmoniously melded and baked to golden perfection. The result is a mouthwatering masterpiece that captures the essence of comfort food with every bite.
Main Menu Items:
1. Chicken Alfredo: House of Como’s Chicken Alfredo is a customer favorite, featuring tender pieces of grilled chicken served atop a bed of fettuccine noodles bathed in a velvety Alfredo sauce. The dish is garnished with a sprinkle of freshly grated Parmesan and a dash of parsley for a touch of elegance.
2. Eggplant Parmesan: For those seeking a meatless option, the Eggplant Parmesan is a standout choice. Slices of eggplant are breaded, fried to a perfect crisp, and layered with marinara sauce and melted mozzarella cheese. It’s a savory and satisfying Italian classic.
3. Margherita Pizza: House of Como’s Margherita Pizza is a celebration of simplicity and quality ingredients. A thin, crispy crust is adorned with ripe tomatoes, fresh basil leaves, creamy mozzarella, and a drizzle of extra-virgin olive oil. It’s a delightful and authentic representation of this classic pizza style.
Customer Reviews:
“House of Como is a hidden gem in Evansville. Their Como’s Classic Lasagna is a slice of heaven on a plate. The cozy atmosphere and friendly service make it one of my go-to spots.”
“The Chicken Alfredo at House of Como is a must-try! The flavors are so rich and comforting. I always feel like I’m part of the family when I dine here.”
“As a pizza lover, I can’t get enough of their Margherita Pizza. It’s simple yet bursting with flavor. House of Como is undoubtedly one of the Evansville top hole-in-the-wall restaurants, and I’m glad I discovered it.”
House of Como, a family-owned haven of Italian culinary tradition, proudly stands as one of the Evansville top hole-in-the-wall restaurants. Their Como’s Classic Lasagna and a menu featuring delights like Chicken Alfredo, Eggplant Parmesan, and Margherita Pizza are a testament to their commitment to crafting exquisite Italian fare.
They are absolutely one of the Evansville top hole-in-the-wall restaurants. With a warm and welcoming atmosphere, this hidden gem in Evansville is a true destination for those seeking authentic and soul-satisfying Italian cuisine. They stand out among the Evansville top hole-in-the-wall restaurants.
3) Yak & Yeti
Address: 815 S Green River Rd.
Yak & Yeti, located in Evansville, IN, is a hidden culinary gem that proudly holds its place as one of the city’s top hole-in-the-wall restaurants. This unassuming establishment is not just a restaurant; it’s an experience. It’s family-owned and operated, reflecting a deep commitment to sharing the authentic flavors of Nepali and Indian cuisine with the community.
Yak & Yeti’s claim to fame is their mouthwatering “Chicken Tikka Masala.” This iconic dish features tender pieces of chicken marinated in a yogurt-based blend of aromatic spices and herbs, roasted to perfection in a tandoor oven, and then simmered in a creamy tomato sauce. The result is a harmonious medley of flavors that tantalize the taste buds.
Main Menu Items:
1. Momos: Yak & Yeti’s Momos are a popular appetizer. These delicate steamed dumplings are filled with a savory mixture of ground meat or vegetables, garlic, ginger, and Himalayan spices. Served with a side of tangy dipping sauce, they offer a delightful burst of flavors in every bite.
2. Lamb Curry: The Lamb Curry at Yak & Yeti is a fragrant and hearty dish. Tender pieces of lamb are slow-cooked in a flavorful blend of spices, onions, tomatoes, and aromatic herbs, resulting in a satisfying and aromatic curry that pairs perfectly with rice or naan.
3. Vegetable Biryani: For vegetarians, the Vegetable Biryani is a true delight. Fragrant basmati rice is cooked with an assortment of fresh vegetables and aromatic spices, creating a colorful and flavorful dish that’s both wholesome and delicious.
Customer Reviews:
“Yak & Yeti is a true hidden treasure in Evansville. The Chicken Tikka Masala is an absolute must-try. The flavors are incredibly authentic, and the family running the place makes you feel like you’re dining at home.”
“I can’t get enough of the Momos here. They’re unlike any dumplings I’ve had before, and that dipping sauce is addictive. Yak & Yeti is undoubtedly one of the Evansville top hole-in-the-wall restaurants.”
“The Lamb Curry at Yak & Yeti is a flavor explosion! The spices are perfectly balanced, and the lamb is so tender. This restaurant is a testament to the rich diversity of cuisine you can find in Evansville.”
Yak & Yeti, a family-owned haven of Nepali and Indian cuisine, proudly stands as one of the Evansville top hole-in-the-wall restaurants. Their signature Chicken Tikka Masala and a menu featuring delights like Momos, Lamb Curry, and Vegetable Biryani showcase their dedication to bringing authentic flavors to the community.
They are another of the Evansville top hole-in-the-wall restaurants. With welcoming hospitality and an unforgettable culinary journey, Yak & Yeti is a must-visit destination for those seeking a taste of the exotic in the heart of Evansville. They deserve to be ranked high among the Evansville top hole-in-the-wall restaurants.
4) Peep Hole Bar
Address: 201 Main St.
The Peep Hole Bar, located in the heart of Evansville, IN, is a well-guarded secret that proudly earns its reputation as one of the city’s top hole-in-the-wall restaurants. This unassuming establishment is family-owned and operated, exuding a warm and welcoming atmosphere that instantly makes you feel like you’re part of the family.
At Peep Hole Bar, the “Loaded Cheese Fries” are the stuff of legend. These crispy, golden fries are generously smothered in a melty blanket of cheddar cheese, crispy bacon bits, and a dollop of creamy sour cream. It’s the ultimate indulgence and the perfect companion to a cold beverage.
Main Menu Items:
1. Peep Hole Burger: The Peep Hole Burger is a classic favorite. A juicy, hand-formed patty is grilled to perfection and served on a toasted bun, accompanied by fresh lettuce, ripe tomatoes, onions, pickles, and your choice of cheese. It’s a no-frills burger that hits all the right notes.
2. Fried Chicken Sandwich: For those craving something fried to perfection, the Fried Chicken Sandwich is a top pick. A crispy, tender chicken breast is served on a soft bun with a smear of mayonnaise, lettuce, and pickles, creating a satisfying combination of crunch and flavor.
3. Breaded Tenderloin: The Breaded Tenderloin at Peep Hole Bar is a local favorite. A hearty, breaded pork tenderloin is deep-fried to a golden brown and served on a bun with lettuce, onions, and pickles. It’s a satisfying, down-to-earth sandwich that captures the essence of comfort food.
Customer Reviews:
“The Peep Hole Bar is a true hidden gem in Evansville. The Loaded Cheese Fries are a guilty pleasure, and their Peep Hole Burger is a no-nonsense classic. The family atmosphere and friendly service make it a favorite among locals.”
“I can’t resist their Fried Chicken Sandwich. It’s crispy, flavorful, and never disappoints. Peep Hole Bar is a must-visit if you’re looking for a down-home meal and a great time.”
“The Breaded Tenderloin at Peep Hole Bar is legendary. It’s big, it’s delicious, and it’s exactly what you want in a sandwich. This place is the definition of one of the Evansville top hole-in-the-wall restaurants.”
Peep Hole Bar, a family-owned establishment with a well-deserved reputation as one of the Evansville top hole-in-the-wall restaurants, offers a comforting menu featuring classics like the Peep Hole Burger, Fried Chicken Sandwich, and Breaded Tenderloin. Their signature Loaded Cheese Fries add an indulgent touch to the experience.
They are obviously one of the Evansville top hole-in-the-wall restaurants. With a welcoming atmosphere and hearty fare, Peep Hole Bar is a popular local spot that captures the essence of good food and good company in the heart of Evansville. They have earned the rank of being one of the Evansville top hole-in-the-wall restaurants.
5) Cross Eyed Cricket
Address: 2101 W Lloyd Expy.
The Cross Eyed Cricket, nestled in Evansville, IN, is a treasured find that proudly holds its place as one of the city’s top hole-in-the-wall restaurants. This unassuming establishment is a true family-owned and operated gem, where the charm lies in its unpretentious ambiance and dedication to serving hearty, homestyle food.
Cross Eyed Cricket’s claim to fame is their “Cricket Burger.” This iconic creation features a perfectly seasoned, handcrafted beef patty cooked to your liking and served on a soft, toasted bun. What sets it apart is the Cricket Sauce – a secret family recipe that adds a unique and irresistible flavor profile to this popular burger.
Main Menu Items:
1. Chicken Fried Steak: The Chicken Fried Steak at Cross Eyed Cricket is a comforting classic. A tender, breaded steak cutlet is fried to a crispy golden brown and smothered in rich, creamy country-style gravy. Served with a choice of sides, it’s a hearty and satisfying dish.
2. Pulled Pork Sandwich: For barbecue enthusiasts, the Pulled Pork Sandwich is a standout choice. Tender, slow-cooked pulled pork is piled high on a bun and drizzled with the house barbecue sauce. Coleslaw provides a refreshing crunch and balance of flavors.
3. Loaded Baked Potato: The Loaded Baked Potato is a favorite side dish at Cross Eyed Cricket. A perfectly baked potato is loaded with butter, sour cream, shredded cheddar cheese, crispy bacon bits, and chives. It’s the ultimate comfort food sidekick.
Customer Reviews:
“Cross Eyed Cricket is a true hidden gem in Evansville. The Cricket Burger is unlike any other burger I’ve tasted, and that secret Cricket Sauce is what dreams are made of. It’s the embodiment of one of the Evansville top hole-in-the-wall restaurants.”
“The Chicken Fried Steak here is a nostalgia trip back to my grandma’s kitchen. It’s crispy on the outside, tender on the inside, and that country gravy is divine. Cross Eyed Cricket is a must-visit for comfort food lovers.”
“I can’t get enough of their Pulled Pork Sandwich and Loaded Baked Potato. The barbecue is top-notch, and the potato is loaded to the max. Cross Eyed Cricket’s warm and welcoming atmosphere makes it feel like you’re dining with family.”
Cross Eyed Cricket, a family-owned haven of homestyle comfort food, proudly stands as one of the Evansville top hole-in-the-wall restaurants. Their signature Cricket Burger and a menu featuring classics like Chicken Fried Steak, Pulled Pork Sandwich, and Loaded Baked Potato showcase their commitment to satisfying the cravings of locals and visitors alike. They are considered one of the Evansville top hole-in-the-wall restaurants.
With a down-to-earth atmosphere and a focus on heartwarming cuisine, Cross Eyed Cricket is a popular destination for those seeking a taste of home in the heart of Evansville. They deserve to be ranked among the Evansville top hole-in-the-wall restaurants.
Now you know why these are some of the Evansville top hole-in-the-wall restaurants just waiting for you to discover them. However, it’s important to let you know that this is not an exhaustive list of the Evansville top hole-in-the-wall restaurants and that this list is in no particular order.
Venture beyond the familiar and well-trodden paths of dining, and you’ll find that Evansville’s gastronomic secrets are abundant and diverse. From cozy family-owned establishments to tucked-away culinary gems, Evansville has an impressive array of dining options that celebrate the spirit of homemade, authentic, and unforgettable food.
These Evansville top hole-in-the-wall restaurants are not only a testament to the city’s rich culinary heritage but also a reflection of the warmth and hospitality that define the Evansville dining experience.
While we’ve explored five outstanding Evansville top hole-in-the-wall restaurants, there is a world of gastronomic delights waiting for you to discover. So, set out with an open mind and a hungry heart, and let Evansville’s hidden culinary treasures surprise and delight you, one unforgettable meal at a time.
You May Want to Join The World Recipes With Our Big Escape
Share your own recipes in our Facebook Group. Find recipes from all over the world. Learn more about International Cuisine and how you can surprise you family with new and exciting foods from all over the world.
For More Photos Visit Our Instagram at World Recipes Daily – Our Big Escape
