5 Top Hole-in-the-Wall Restaurants in New York

5 Top Hole-in-the-Wall Restaurants in New York

5 Top Hole-in-the-Wall Restaurants in New York

These 5 Top Hole-in-the-Wall Restaurants in New York — Russ & Daughters, John’s of Bleecker Street, Eisenberg’s Sandwich Shop, Mamoun’s Falafel, and Gracie Mews Diner—offer a diverse range of culinary delights that reflect the vibrant food scene of the city. From the iconic Jewish deli experience at Russ & Daughters to the mouthwatering pizzas at John’s of Bleecker Street, the timeless sandwiches at Eisenberg’s, the flavorful Middle Eastern cuisine at Mamoun’s Falafel, and the comforting American classics at Gracie Mews Diner, each of these establishments has carved its own niche and earned a dedicated following. Now you know why they are one of the best restaurants in New York for you to discover.

Want more ideas to round-out your restaurant search?
A lot of great options are in these posts!
5 Top Burger Joints in New York City
Top 5 Barbecue Restaurants in New York City

1. Russ & Daughters

A Hidden Gem of New York’s Culinary Scene
Address: 179 East Houston Street, New York, NY 10002
Phone Number: (212) 475-4880

Russ & Daughters is one of the top hole-in-the-wall restaurants in New York. A cherished and renowned hole-in-the-wall restaurant located in the Lower East Side of Manhattan, New York. It has been operating for over a century, first opening its doors in 1914, and has remained a family-owned and operated establishment ever since. This culinary gem specializes in traditional Jewish fare and is famous for its outstanding selection of smoked fish, caviar, bagels, and other delicacies.

One of Russ & Daughters’ most revered offerings is their classic smoked salmon. Known for its exceptional quality and delightful flavors, their smoked salmon is hand-sliced and cured to perfection. The salmon is carefully selected and smoked in-house, resulting in a melt-in-your-mouth texture and a rich, smoky taste. Served on a freshly baked bagel with a schmear of cream cheese, red onions, and capers, it is a quintessential New York delicacy that has garnered a cult following.

Main Menu Items:

1. “The Classic Bagel and Lox”: This iconic menu item features Russ & Daughters’ renowned hand-sliced smoked salmon, nestled on a freshly baked bagel. It is traditionally garnished with cream cheese, red onions, and capers, providing a harmonious blend of flavors.

2. “The Nosh Platter”: This generously portioned platter offers a delightful assortment of Russ & Daughters’ delicacies. It includes a selection of their finest smoked fish, such as smoked salmon, sable, and whitefish, alongside pickled herring, cream cheese, tomatoes, onions, and bagels. Perfect for sharing or indulging on your own.

3. “The Caviar Sampler”: For caviar enthusiasts, this menu item presents an extraordinary experience. The sampler showcases a variety of premium caviars sourced from around the world, paired with blinis, crème fraîche, and traditional accompaniments, allowing guests to savor the luxury and complexity of these exquisite delicacies.

4. “The Matzo Ball Soup”: A comforting classic, Russ & Daughters’ matzo ball soup is a testament to their dedication to Jewish cuisine. The hearty soup features a flavorful broth with tender matzo balls, aromatic vegetables, and savory herbs, offering a taste of tradition and comfort.

Customer Reviews:

“Russ & Daughters is an absolute treasure! The bagels and lox are simply unmatched. Every bite is an explosion of flavors. The staff is friendly and the atmosphere is cozy. A must-visit for anyone seeking an authentic taste of New York.”

“I cannot express how much I adore Russ & Daughters. The smoked salmon is like nothing I’ve ever tasted before. It’s always fresh and perfectly smoked. The Nosh Platter is a work of art, and the caviar sampler is a luxurious treat. This place is a culinary heaven.”

“Russ & Daughters is a time capsule of flavors and traditions. Their matzo ball soup takes me back to my grandma’s kitchen. It’s like a warm hug in a bowl. I highly recommend this place for anyone craving authentic Jewish cuisine.”

Russ & Daughters is one of the exceptional hole-in-the-wall restaurants in New York City that has captured the hearts and taste buds of locals and visitors alike. With over a century of operation, this family-owned establishment has become an institution, offering an array of traditional Jewish delicacies. From their renowned smoked salmon to their indulgent caviar sampler, every dish at Russ & Daughters showcases the highest quality ingredients and a commitment to preserving the flavors of Jewish heritage. With a cozy ambiance and friendly service, a visit to Russ & Daughters is a culinary journey into the heart of New York’s rich gastronomic history. They rank in the top hole-in-the-wall restaurants in New York for good reasons.

2. John’s of Bleecker Street

A Timeless Gem in New York’s Culinary Landscape
Address: 278 Bleecker Street, New York, NY 10014
Phone Number: (212) 243-1680

John’s of Bleecker Street is one of the popular hole-in-the-wall restaurants in New York. A legendary hole-in-the-wall restaurant situated in the vibrant neighborhood of Greenwich Village in New York City. Since 1929, this family-owned and operated establishment has been delighting locals and visitors with its classic Italian-American cuisine. Stepping into John’s of Bleecker Street is like entering a time capsule, where the old-world charm and warm atmosphere transport you to a bygone era.

The signature dish at John’s of Bleecker Street is their renowned coal-fired brick oven pizza. Baked to perfection in their historic oven, this pizza embodies the essence of traditional Neapolitan-style pizza. The crust is thin and slightly charred, offering a delightful crispness, while the toppings are of the highest quality, from the tangy tomato sauce to the gooey mozzarella cheese. Each bite of their pizza is a flavorful journey that captivates the senses.

Main Menu Items:

1. “Margherita Pizza”: A timeless classic, John’s Margherita Pizza features a thin, crispy crust topped with a vibrant tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella cheese, and basil leaves. This simple yet heavenly combination highlights the authentic flavors of a traditional Neapolitan pizza.

2. “Pepperoni Pizza”: For those craving a meaty indulgence, John’s Pepperoni Pizza is a must-try. The flavorful pepperoni slices are generously scattered atop the bubbling cheese and tangy tomato sauce, creating a harmony of spicy and savory notes that pizza lovers adore.

3. “Lasagna”: John’s Lasagna is a comforting and hearty dish that showcases their expertise in Italian-American cuisine. Layers of pasta are delicately cooked with a rich meat sauce, creamy ricotta, and melted mozzarella cheese, resulting in a lasagna that is both satisfying and nostalgic.

4. “Spaghetti and Meatballs”: This classic pasta dish exemplifies the essence of John’s of Bleecker Street. Al dente spaghetti is served with their signature meatballs, made from a secret family recipe, and topped with a robust marinara sauce. It is a comforting and flavorful choice that will transport you to Italian grandma’s kitchen.

Customer Reviews:

“John’s of Bleecker Street has the best pizza in the city, hands down. The crust is perfection, and the toppings are always fresh and flavorful. The cozy atmosphere and friendly staff make every visit a memorable experience.”

“I’ve been coming to John’s for years, and it never disappoints. Their lasagna is like a warm hug on a plate, and their meatballs are out of this world. It’s the kind of place where you feel like part of the family.”

“John’s is a true New York institution. The coal-fired pizza is unlike anything else, with its crispy crust and mouthwatering toppings. You can taste the tradition and history in every bite. It’s a must-visit for any pizza lover.”

John’s of Bleecker Street, one of the top restaurants in New York, is a timeless gem nestled in the heart of Greenwich Village, offering a glimpse into New York’s rich culinary heritage. As a family-owned and operated establishment, this beloved hole-in-the-wall restaurant has been serving exceptional Italian-American cuisine since 1929. With their signature coal-fired brick oven pizza stealing the show, alongside comforting classics like lasagna and spaghetti with meatballs, John’s of Bleecker Street continues to charm diners with its warm ambiance, top-notch fare, and unwavering commitment to tradition. They stand out among the top hole-in-the-wall restaurants in New York.

3. Eisenberg’s Sandwich Shop

A Time-Honored Deli Experience in New York City
Address: 174 5th Avenue, New York, NY 10010
Phone Number: (212) 675-5096

Eisenberg’s Sandwich Shop is another of the top hole-in-the-wall restaurants in New York. A cherished hole-in-the-wall deli located in the Flatiron District of New York City. Operating since 1929, this family-owned and operated establishment has stood the test of time, maintaining its commitment to serving classic deli fare with warmth and authenticity. Eisenberg’s captures the essence of a quintessential New York deli, offering a nostalgic and unpretentious dining experience that has garnered a loyal following.

Eisenberg’s Sandwich Shop is best known for its signature sandwich, the “Eisenberg’s Reuben.” This iconic creation combines layers of thinly sliced corned beef, tangy sauerkraut, melted Swiss cheese, and Russian dressing, all sandwiched between slices of rye bread. Grilled to perfection, the Eisenberg’s Reuben embodies the perfect balance of flavors and textures, making it a must-try for any sandwich enthusiast.

Main Menu Items:

1. “Pastrami on Rye”: A true classic, Eisenberg’s Pastrami on Rye is a sandwich lover’s delight. Generous portions of tender, thinly sliced pastrami are piled high on fresh rye bread, creating a flavorful and satisfying combination. It’s a time-honored choice that exemplifies the art of the New York deli.

2. “Matzo Ball Soup”: Eisenberg’s Matzo Ball Soup is a comforting dish that brings warmth to the soul. The flavorful chicken broth is accompanied by a fluffy matzo ball, tender chunks of chicken, and aromatic vegetables, offering a taste of Jewish tradition and culinary comfort.

3. “Turkey Club”: For a classic deli sandwich with a twist, the Turkey Club at Eisenberg’s hits the mark. Stacked high with roasted turkey breast, crispy bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise, all layered between toasted bread, this sandwich is a delightful combination of textures and flavors.

4. “Tuna Melt”: Eisenberg’s Tuna Melt is a beloved choice for seafood lovers. A generous portion of tuna salad, made with the perfect blend of mayo and seasonings, is topped with melted cheese and grilled to perfection. Served on your choice of bread, it’s a delicious and comforting option.

Customer Reviews:

“Eisenberg’s Sandwich Shop is a hidden gem in the heart of the city. The Reuben sandwich is out of this world, with the perfect balance of flavors and a satisfying crunch. The atmosphere takes you back in time, and the staff is friendly and attentive.”

“I’ve been coming to Eisenberg’s for years, and it never disappoints. Their pastrami is second to none, and the Matzo Ball Soup is pure comfort in a bowl. This place is a true New York institution that always feels like home.”

“Eisenberg’s is the real deal. The sandwiches are made with love and care, and the flavors are unparalleled. The Turkey Club is a personal favorite, with layers of deliciousness in every bite. Don’t miss this gem of a deli.”

Eisenberg’s Sandwich Shop is one of the restaurants in New York that is a time-honored establishment that has captured the hearts and taste buds of New Yorkers and visitors alike. With its prime location in the Flatiron District and a legacy dating back to 1929, this family-owned deli offers an authentic taste of classic New York deli fare. From their legendary Reuben sandwich to comforting Matzo Ball Soup and satisfying turkey club, Eisenberg’s continues to be a go-to destination for those seeking an unpretentious, nostalgic deli experience in the bustling city. They deserve to be ranked among the top hole-in-the-wall restaurants in New York.

4. Mamoun’s Falafel

A Flavorful Haven of Middle Eastern Cuisine in New York City
Address: 119 MacDougal Street, New York, NY 10012
Phone Number: (212) 674-8685

Mamoun’s Falafel is one of the favorite hole-in-the-wall restaurants in New York. A favorite hole-in-the-wall restaurant nestled in the heart of Greenwich Village, New York City. Since 1971, this family-owned and operated establishment has been a beacon of authentic Middle Eastern cuisine, captivating locals and tourists alike. Mamoun’s exudes an inviting and casual ambiance, inviting diners to indulge in a diverse menu of flavorful dishes inspired by the rich culinary traditions of the Middle East.

The signature dish at Mamoun’s Falafel is, unsurprisingly, their namesake falafel. Mamoun’s falafel is a true culinary masterpiece, featuring a blend of ground chickpeas, herbs, and spices, meticulously formed into crispy, golden-brown spheres. Served in a warm pita pocket and garnished with fresh vegetables, tahini sauce, and a sprinkle of aromatic spices, Mamoun’s falafel offers a harmonious combination of textures and flavors that is simply irresistible.

Main Menu Items:

1. “Falafel Sandwich”: A must-try at Mamoun’s, the Falafel Sandwich showcases their famous falafel nestled in a warm pita bread alongside a medley of crisp lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, onions, and drizzled with tangy tahini sauce. It is a delightful vegetarian option bursting with bold flavors.

2. “Chicken Shawarma Platter”: This delectable platter features marinated and perfectly grilled slices of tender chicken shawarma, served with fluffy basmati rice, a side of fresh salad, and topped with creamy garlic sauce. It is a satisfying and savory choice that showcases the skillful mastery of Middle Eastern cuisine.

3. “Lamb Kebab”: The Lamb Kebab at Mamoun’s is a carnivore’s delight. Skewered and grilled to perfection, the succulent lamb pieces are infused with aromatic spices, resulting in a tender and flavorful experience. Served with warm pita bread, hummus, and a refreshing salad, it is a tantalizing option for meat lovers.

4. “Baba Ganoush”: This classic Middle Eastern appetizer is a delightful addition to any meal. Mamoun’s Baba Ganoush features smoky roasted eggplant blended with tahini, garlic, lemon juice, and a hint of olive oil. Served with warm pita bread, it offers a creamy and rich dip that tantalizes the taste buds.

Customer Reviews:

“Mamoun’s Falafel is an absolute gem! The falafel is crispy on the outside, fluffy on the inside, and bursting with flavor. The Chicken Shawarma Platter is a favorite of mine – the chicken is tender and juicy, and the garlic sauce is heavenly.”

“You haven’t experienced true falafel until you’ve been to Mamoun’s. Their falafel is legendary, and their pita bread is always fresh and warm. The Lamb Kebab is melt-in-your-mouth delicious. This place is a go-to for authentic Middle Eastern cuisine.”

“Mamoun’s Falafel is a culinary treasure. Their food is made with love and passion, and it shows in every bite. The Baba Ganoush is creamy and addictive, and their falafel sandwich is a flavor explosion. The friendly staff and vibrant atmosphere make it a must-visit spot.”

Mamoun’s Falafel has established itself as one of the top restaurants in New York and a haven for Middle Eastern cuisine enthusiasts in the heart of Greenwich Village. With its family-owned heritage spanning over five decades, this humble hole-in-the-wall eatery continues to serve exceptional falafel, alongside a range of flavorful dishes that celebrate the diverse flavors of the Middle East. Mamoun’s unwavering commitment to quality, coupled with its warm and inviting atmosphere, has made it a go-to destination for both locals and visitors seeking an authentic culinary experience. They have earned the rank of being one of the top hole-in-the-wall restaurants in New York.

5. Gracie Mews Diner

Address: 984 1st Avenue, New York, NY 10022
Phone Number: (212) 988-9878

Gracie Mews Diner is one of the popular hole-in-the-wall restaurants in New York. A charming hole-in-the-wall restaurant located in the Upper East Side of New York City. Operating for over two decades, this family-owned and operated establishment has become a beloved fixture in the neighborhood. Gracie Mews Diner offers a quintessential diner experience, serving a diverse menu of American comfort food with a touch of Mediterranean influence. With its cozy atmosphere and friendly service, it has become a go-to spot for locals and visitors alike.

Gracie Mews Diner is known for its mouthwatering “Greek Salad.” This signature dish showcases a vibrant mix of fresh and crisp lettuce, juicy tomatoes, cucumbers, red onions, kalamata olives, and tangy feta cheese. Tossed in a zesty dressing with a hint of lemon, the Greek Salad at Gracie Mews Diner offers a refreshing and flavorful combination that perfectly captures the essence of Mediterranean cuisine.

Main Menu Items:

1. “Classic Cheeseburger”: This staple of American diner fare features a juicy beef patty topped with melted cheese, lettuce, tomato, onions, pickles, and a special sauce. Served with a side of golden fries, the Classic Cheeseburger is a satisfying choice for burger enthusiasts.

2. “Chicken Souvlaki Platter”: A Mediterranean-inspired dish, the Chicken Souvlaki Platter showcases tender marinated chicken skewers, accompanied by fluffy rice pilaf, grilled pita bread, and a refreshing side of tzatziki sauce. It’s a flavorful and satisfying option for those seeking a taste of Greek cuisine.

3. “Egg Benedict”: Gracie Mews Diner’s take on this breakfast classic features perfectly poached eggs served on a toasted English muffin with Canadian bacon and topped with rich hollandaise sauce. Served with a side of crispy home fries, the Egg Benedict is a beloved choice for a hearty and indulgent breakfast.

4. “Penne alla Vodka”: This Italian-inspired pasta dish combines al dente penne pasta with a creamy and flavorful vodka tomato sauce. Finished with a sprinkle of Parmesan cheese and served with garlic bread, Penne alla Vodka is a comforting choice that satisfies any pasta craving.

Customer Reviews:

“Gracie Mews Diner is a hidden gem in the neighborhood. The Greek Salad is incredibly fresh and packed with flavor. The staff is friendly and attentive, and the cozy atmosphere makes it a perfect spot for a casual meal.”

“I’ve been coming to Gracie Mews Diner for years, and it never disappoints. The Chicken Souvlaki Platter is my go-to choice, with its perfectly grilled chicken and delicious tzatziki sauce. The prices are reasonable, and the portion sizes are generous.”

“Gracie Mews Diner has that classic diner charm. Their Classic Cheeseburger is juicy and delicious, and their Egg Benedict is the perfect way to start the day. It’s a neighborhood favorite that feels like home.”

Gracie Mews Diner, nestled in the Upper East Side, is a beloved family-owned diner that has been serving comforting American and Mediterranean-inspired dishes for over two decades. With its cozy ambiance and friendly service, it has become one of the top restaurants in New York as a go-to spot for locals seeking a satisfying meal. Whether enjoying their signature Greek Salad, savoring a classic cheeseburger, indulging in Chicken Souvlaki, or starting the day with a delicious Egg Benedict, Gracie Mews Diner offers a warm and inviting dining experience that captures the essence of a classic New York diner. They can definitely be counted among the top hole-in-the-wall restaurants in New York.

So, while we celebrate the delights offered by Russ & Daughters, John’s of Bleecker Street, Eisenberg’s Sandwich Shop, Mamoun’s Falafel, and Gracie Mews Diner, let’s not forget to venture off the beaten path and explore the countless other exceptional hole-in-the-wall restaurants in New York City. The city’s culinary landscape is brimming with surprises, and there’s always something new and delicious waiting to be uncovered around every corner. This is why they are one of the best restaurants in New York for you to discover.

However, it’s important to note that this list is by no means exhaustive. New York City is teeming with hidden culinary gems, and the world of hole-in-the-wall restaurants extends far beyond these five establishments. If you’re a barbecue enthusiast, for example, there are numerous outstanding hole-in-the-wall BBQ joints waiting to be discovered throughout the city.

You May Want to Join The World Recipes With Our Big Escape
Share your own recipes in our Facebook Group. Find recipes from all over the world. Learn more about International Cuisine and how you can surprise you family with new and exciting foods from all over the world.

For More Photos Visit Our Instagram at World Recipes Daily – Our Big Escape

Scroll to Top